4/16/2023 0 Comments Shotbot stackoverflow![]() It's just not feasible, for a number of very good reasons. (Image source: Atta Kenare, Getty Images)ĭownvotes are important for the health of the site, and mandating comments for them would massively impede the way Stack Overflow currently works-to the point of potentially destroying it. The importance of each individual diminishes, relative to the whole. In order to survive, big cities need different rules than small villages-and tend to feel more anonymous and harsh as a result. While big cities can offer tremendous benefits (for Stack Overflow, the analogy is a dense concentration of expertise), they also experience unique issues relating to the lack of resource scaling, including traffic, congestion, and pollution. What is not commonly understood or even immediately obvious to the casual observer is that Stack Overflow has become a big city. (In fact, that's not the purpose or intention of downvotes at all!) ![]() Learn more.įorcing downvotes to be accompanied by a comment sounds like a good idea at first blush, and many here would like to see new users get all the info they need to ask questions that are a better fit! Contrary to popular opinion, most users here are kind and want to help rather than enjoying "shooting down" newbies' questions with downvotes to make them feel bad and unwelcome. Comments on this answer have been disabled, but it is still accepting other interactions. (Image source: "Norwegian Troll", by Ivar Rodningen) Is it because people here are curmudgeonly trolls who just hate people and don't want new users to feel welcome? However, whenever someone suggests one of these changes on Meta, it gets unceremoniously rejected and (ironically) downvoted without a detailed explanation! Downvotes should cost reputation points unless accompanied by a comment.The first downvote should be accompanied by a mandatory comment.Downvotes should be accompanied by a reason selected from a drop-down menu.Downvotes should be accompanied by a mandatory, anonymous comment. ![]() Every downvote should be accompanied by a mandatory comment.Several ideas have been proposed for how to fix this, including: Stack Overflow's rules can be difficult to grasp, especially for newbies, and downvotes can feel hostile and discouraging. It seems like this is especially bad for new users, who are made to feel unwelcome by veteran users. Even worse, sometimes I just get snarky comments! Sometimes my post receives downvotes with no explanation on what I've done wrong. It is not currently accepting new answers or interactions. Edit existing answers to improve this post. This question's answers are a community effort.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |